Updated Monday, July 28, 2014 as of 6:28 AM ET
Blogs - Trial and Heirs
Huguette Clark Case Illustrates Importance of Proper Estate Planning
Tuesday, November 29, 2011

The sum includes $3 million spent on dolls and about $2 million on the attorney’s favorite charity.  There was even $1.85 million paid to an Israeli settlement in which Bock’s daughter lived.  The hospital’s price tag was nearly $5 million, which would not seem out-of-line for 22 years of time Clark spent there, except that she was reportedly in good health for most of that time.

Not surprisingly, Clark’s distant family members are questioning everything and have filed to challenge the validity of Clark’s will.  If they win, 21 distant family members will inherit her wealth, instead of her art foundation and the other named beneficiaries.

In addition to claiming mental incompetency, the challenge undoubtedly will focus on the allegation of undue influence. That is when a person, or people, uses coercion or other improper means to convince someone to leave them assets (such as through a will) when the person wouldn’t have otherwise done so.

This will be a big question in this case, for several reasons. First, the attorney and accountant held power of attorney over Clark.  Second, there were her odd and isolated living arrangements.  Finally, Bock and Kamsler were both named as will beneficiaries — not to mention that they stand to receive $16 million or more in executor fees (according to the MSNBC.com report).  They clearly will not have an easy fight on their hands defending themselves and the will.

In New York, as in most states, the law will actually assume undue influence existed in certain circumstances. This happens when someone had a trusted, confidential relationship with the person in question (such as would exist with a power of attorney or an attorney-client relationship) and that trusted person benefited from the will, especially where the same person or people were somehow involved in the will preparation process. While this law varies from state to state, in New York it means that Bock and Kamsler will have to present evidence that the will was done without improper influence by them. This is not a simple legal hurdle to clear under the circumstances of this case.

The sad part is that if Clark did indeed want to benefit a charitable foundation rather than her distant family members, precautions could have been taken to protect those wishes. If her will is ultimately stricken based on undue influence by her attorney and accountant, then none of the wishes in her will would be followed.

This is a valuable lesson for clients, even for those with fortunes of far less value than $400 million. Whenever there is a will or trust done under circumstances that are questionable or which could lead to a lawsuit later, extra care should be used to make sure that the documents are done the right way.  This can include getting a neutral law firm involved, or even videotaping the will or trust execution to show that the person really did intend what the document says.

These lawsuits are never fun for anyone, no matter how much is involved, so the more care that can be taken to prevent them, the better.

UpdateMSNBC recently posted a new court filing by Huguette Clark’s family members, which included an earlier will dated only six weeks before the April 2005 will.  This prior will left $5 million to Clark’s nurse, Hadassah Peri, and the rest to her family members. Interestingly, Wally Bock prepared and supervised this prior will, which is as different from the newer will as night and day.

Why the sudden change of heart over the course of six weeks? That’s what Clark’s family members are asking. This certainly makes their undue influence case that much stronger, and deepens the mysteries that will surely be explored through the litigation.  This also calls into serious question whether Clark did indeed wish to create an art foundation, managed by Bock, Kamsler and an additional attorney, as spelled out in her most recent will.

Certainly people can and do change their final intentions, even in a short time frame, but the circumstances surrounding the two wills is very interesting, to say the least.


By Danielle and Andy Mayoras, co-authors of Trial & Heirs: Famous Fortune Fights!, husband-and-wife legacy expert attorneys, and hosts of the national television special, Trial & Heirs:  Protect Your Family Fortune! For the latest celebrity and high-profile cases, with tips to protect yourself, your loved ones, and your clients, click here to subscribe to The Trial & Heirs Update.  You can “like” them on Facebook and follow them on Twitter.



(2) Comments
Proper Estate Planning is really important. I consider Clark've created some genuinely exciting points. Not too most people would in reality consider about this the way he simply did. I'm really impressed that there's a lot about this topic that's been uncovered and he also did it so tremendously, with a lot class. Thanks for sharing this post. drug and alcohol detox
Posted by alice d | Monday, February 27 2012 at 2:55AM ET
Pozostałe niebezpieczeństwo twardnieje się spośrod postraszeniem kulturowym. - Mamy obecnie w Polsce oprowadzaną nawałę kulturową, jaka dysponuje zniszczyć materiałem wybuchowym w powietrze krajową tradycję nienacjonalistyczną wizy usa - mierzy stary. Haftuje adnotację, że całe zależności, z rodem na czele, stawiane na krzyż stulecia, jakie w dalszym ciągu w ostatnim czasie donosiły się niemożliwe aż do zrujnowania, są w tej chwili zbijane. Ten mechanizm, jaki wizy usa raz Dmowski przedstawił terminami, iż o ile ociupinę stanowi na Zachodzie grypą, to obok nas gruźlicą, być może się przetestować - ostrzega.
Posted by misiek m | Tuesday, June 25 2013 at 11:36AM ET
Post a Comment
You must be registered to post a comment.
Not Registered?
You must be registered to post a comment. Click here to register.
Already registered? Log in here
Please note you must now log in with your email address and password.
2014 Summer Reading List for Advisors

Current Issue

The June Issue is now online!


Industry Events

August 10, 2014 |

September 9, 2014 |

September 17, 2014 |

September 20, 2014 |

September 28, 2014 |

Already a subscriber? Log in here