Updated Friday, August 1, 2014 as of 6:33 PM ET
Blogs - Trial and Heirs
Archie Comics Power Struggle Provides Valuable Succession Planning Lessons
Wednesday, April 18, 2012

Just because two business partners get along well doesn’t mean the next generation will do so too. When succession planning is done in advance, restrictions — or at the very least, mechanisms to dictate how decisions will be made and what procedures are to be used in case of disagreement – can be used to avoid messy, protracted battles.

A recent New York Times article, The Battle for a Comic-Book Empire That Archie Built, detailed the ongoing legal battle over the two dueling CEOs of Archie Comic Publications. The story of the fight can be a vivid illustration for advisors’ clients about why it’s important to work with experienced estate planning attorneys, particularly those skilled in business succession planning, when there is a family business.  No one thinks that ugly feuds like this one can happen. But they do, and proper legal planning done in advance is the best source of prevention.

On one side of the Archie Comics battle is Jonathan Goldwater, the son of John L. Goldwater who was one of three founders of the company and the visionary behind the Archie character, created in 1941. Goldwater became a co-CEO and controller of one-half interest in the company after his half-brother, Richard Goldwater, died in 2007.

Nancy Silberkleit is the widow of the son of another founder, Louis Silberkleit. She was a schoolteacher who became co-CEO when her husband, Michael Silberkleit, died in 2008.  By that time, a long-time employee and editor-in-chief, Victor Gorelick, was running the company as a temporary, stop-gap measure.

Goldwater and Silberkleit tried to work together to manage the company, agreeing in 2009 to run Archie Comics by sharing CEO duties. Silberkleit was to oversee scholastic and theatrical ventures, placing Goldwater in charge of everything else. They were supposed to consult with each other on major decisions.

So what happened? Let’s just say that the idyllic Riverdale community, which Archie and his friends call home, wouldn’t approve. Goldwater claims Silberkleit abuses her power on a scale that would fit in with the movie, Horrible Bosses.  As the Associated Press described it, Goldwater and others accuse her of being “a volatile, abrasive menace who has sexually harassed employees with vulgar remarks, made bad business moves and even paraded a former football player around the office to intimidate people.”

Smartest Takeaways From the Women Advisors Forum

Silberkleit denies it all, of course, and says Goldwater is trying to steal the company from her, has defamed her, and that he’s a chauvinist who has tried to lock her out of the company finances. She even accuses him of puncturing car tires.

They’ve filed lawsuits against each other. So far, Goldwater appears to be winning. A New York Judge in one of the cases entered a temporary restraining order against Silberkleit, banning her from the company, preventing her from speaking about the lawsuit and from representing Archie Comics in any way.  

Silberkleit then violated the order twice and was ordered to pay nearly $60,000 in fines and legal expenses. Goldwater, meanwhile, has been allowed to run the company without her during the legal battle.

The parties are now trying to mediate the dispute and find an end to their differences. Given the nature of the allegations, this seems unlikely.

So where’s the lesson in all of this? Before the dueling CEOs’ predecessors, Richard Goldwater and Michael Silberkleit, died in 2007 and 2008 respectively — both from cancer — they should have done the proper succession planning to have the business taken over by responsible leaders who could cooperate.

Instead, Jonathan Goldwater bought his interest from Richard’s Estate, and Michael’s shares passed to his widow. A long-time employee was forced to run the company on an emergency basis, and that proved to be only a peaceful interlude to the nasty battle that followed.

Would Richard and Michael — or their fathers, who founded the company for that matter — have wanted the Archie enterprise to descend into such a bitter and ugly court fight? Of course not. With thoughtful, advance succession planning for the business, this could have been avoided.

This story can be a great conversation starter for your clients who own interests in closely-held businesses. Have they done their succession planning yet? Or have they procrastinated, not wanting to think about what will happen to their business when they pass.

It’s especially important when a business is run by two equal partners, or may pass in equal shares to heirs.  These situations can create deadlocks and worse. Corporate documents like buy-sell and shareholders agreements, and stock restrictions, can ensure that ownership interests don’t pass onto heirs of someone who dies, without the permission of the company or the co-owner, or at least without protections in place.


By Danielle and Andy Mayoras, co-authors of Trial & Heirs: Famous Fortune Fights!, husband-and-wife legacy expert attorneys, and hosts of the national television special, Trial & Heirs:  Protect Your Family Fortune! For the latest celebrity and high-profile cases, with tips to protect yourself, your loved ones, and your clients, click here to subscribe to The Trial & Heirs Update.  You can “like” them on Facebook and follow them on Twitter



(1) Comment
Drugie ryzyko krzepnie się spośrod postraszeniem kulturowym. - Maci obecnie w Polsce przeważoną agresję kulturową, ktora posiada wysadzić w powietrze w atmosfera polską wizy usa tradycję nieetniczną - taksuje dyrektor. Adresuje czujność, że niecałe układy, spośrod familią na czele, podnoszone za pomocą stulecia, ktore w dalszym ciągu wizy do usa niedawno wyjawiały się niedopuszczalne aż do zrujnowania, stanowią w owej sekundy kwestionowane. Ow mechanizm, jaki pewnego dnia Dmowski zaprezentował terminami, iż jeśliby trochę istnieje na Okcydencie grypą, owo u nas gruźlicą, prawdopodobnie się stwierdzić - upomni.
Posted by misiek m | Tuesday, June 25 2013 at 10:43AM ET
Post a Comment
You must be registered to post a comment.
Not Registered?
You must be registered to post a comment. Click here to register.
Already registered? Log in here
Please note you must now log in with your email address and password.
2014 Summer Reading List for Advisors

Current Issue

The June Issue is now online!


Industry Events

August 10, 2014 |

September 9, 2014 |

September 17, 2014 |

September 20, 2014 |

September 28, 2014 |

Already a subscriber? Log in here