In the past year or so, I’ve personally taken two risk profile questionnaires. The first, by Vanguard, pegged my stock allocation at 70%, while the second, from Wealthfront, put me at 91% stocks and commodities. In reality, I’m about 45% in risky assets and not about to change.

Though risk profile questionnaires are flawed in assuming the way we feel about risk is stable, a much bigger flaw is that they look only at willingness to take risk and ignore our client’s need to take risk.

Clients’ portfolios are stored energy that gives them the freedom to do what they want with their lives. Passing wealth on to heirs is an important goal, but it’s not the clients’ primary goal.
Take, for example two 65-year-old clients who each have a $2 million portfolio. The first needs $150,000 annually beyond Social Security to fund his lifestyle, while the second needs only an additional $50,000. They may both have a high willingness to take risk, but the second client has a very low need.

Because stocks are far riskier than high-quality bonds, the second client may need only a small amount of riskier stock assets while the first client has a much greater need for equities. As the advisor and author William Bernstein puts it, the second client has won the game and needs to quit playing.

Because I live fairly frugally, my need to take risk is low and having even 70% risky assets would be too high. There is always a possibility that stocks will decline by 88%, as they did in the Great Depression. The world is a risky place with unrest in the Mideast, Ukraine and North Korea, and terrorism is far from defeated.

So while a stock collapse isn’t a prediction, it’s certainly a significant possibility. Those with no need for risk in their portfolios -- because they have enough stored energy to meet their needs for the rest of their lives -- shouldn’t take the risk. On the other hand, the very wealthy can build a lifestyle portfolio of U.S. government-backed fixed income and invest the rest of the portfolio for future generations.

Allan S. Roth, a Financial Planning contributing writer, is founder of the planning firm Wealth Logic in Colorado Springs, Colo. He also writes for CBS MoneyWatch.com and has taught investing at three universities.

Allan S. Roth

Allan S. Roth

Allan S. Roth, a Financial Planning contributing writer, is founder of the planning firm Wealth Logic in Colorado Springs, Colo. He also writes for AARP and has taught investing at three universities.